top of page
Search

The Great Pacifier Debate



Pacifiers have been a staple in many parents' toolkits for decades, yet the debate over their use continues to spark discussions among parents, pediatricians, and therapeutic professionals. While pacifiers offer soothing benefits, they also come with their own set of drawbacks. We want to discuss the pros and cons of pacifiers in order to help parents make informed decisions about when to use and when to lose them.


let's start with the pros...


SIDS prevention: Some studies have suggested that the use of pacifiers during sleep may reduce the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS). While the exact mechanism behind this potential benefit is not fully understood, it's believed that pacifiers may help keep the airway open and prevent infants from falling into a deep sleep, which is associated with an increased risk of SIDS.


Provides comfort: One of the most significant benefits of pacifiers is their ability to comfort infants. The act of sucking on a pacifier can help calm infants, providing them with comfort and security, particularly during times of distress or when they're trying to fall asleep.


Self-soothing skills: Pacifiers can also help infants develop self-soothing skills. By learning to use a pacifier to comfort themselves, infants may become less reliant on parents for soothing, which can be beneficial for both baby and parents.


now let's look at the cons...


Dental issues: Prolonged use of pacifiers, especially beyond the age of two, can potentially lead to dental problems. Constant sucking on a pacifier can cause misalignment of the teeth (malocclusion) or lead to changes in the roof of the mouth (high, narrow palate). This can result in problems such as an overbite, underbite, or open bite, which may require orthodontic treatment to correct.


Dependency: One of the most commonly cited concerns about pacifiers is the risk of dependency. Babies and toddlers who rely heavily on pacifiers for soothing may have difficulty learning to self-soothe without them. This can lead to potential sleep disruptions and increased reliance on the pacifier throughout the day.


Delayed speech: Prolonged pacifier use may also impact speech development. Children learn to communicate by experimenting with sounds and vocalizations, coordinating movements of the lips, tongue, and jaw. Babies may be less inclined to babble, coo, or make other vocalizations when they have a pacifier in their mouths for extended periods.




Did you notice that all of the "pros" talked about pacifier use with infants? And the "cons" were focused on babies and toddlers? Pacifiers are a trusty tool for soothing infants, but here's the deal: once your little gets close to the one-year mark, it is time to bid farewell to that binky. Why? Let's break it down:

As kids grow, so do their mouths and teeth. Prolonged pacifier use, especially beyond that first year, can have detrimental effects on oral development, including misalignment of teeth and changes to the shape of the roof of the mouth. Continued pacifier use may also impact speech development, as it restricts the movement of the lips, tongue, and jaw necessary for forming sounds and words. Your little one will start to pick up on all sorts of sounds and try to imitate them, but a pacifier might hinder their ability to practice those sounds accurately.




Ultimately, the decision to use pacifiers is a personal one that should take into account the individual needs and preferences of both the baby and the parents. It's important for parents to weigh the pros and cons carefully and to monitor their baby's pacifier use to ensure it remains appropriate and beneficial. While pacifiers can offer soothing benefits and potentially reduce the risk of SIDS, they also come with possible drawbacks such as dental issues, dependency, and delayed speech.


Limiting pacifier use, particularly during waking hours and when the baby is engaging in social interactions, can help mitigate the risk of speech delays. Providing plenty of opportunities for face-to-face interactions, talking, singing, and reading to your baby can also support language development. If parents have concerns about their child's speech or language development, consulting with a pediatrician or speech-language pathologist can provide valuable guidance and support.

 

For more information on other topics that impact these developmental areas, like pouches and sippy cups, visit our blog pages on those subjects.

Comments


bottom of page